Finding Text
2024-041 - Unsupported FEMA Reimbursements Federal Program 97.036 - FEMA Disaster Grants - Public Assistance (Presidentially Declared Disasters) Award Numbers PW No. 51 (0) and PW No. 34(0) Federal Agency Department of Homeland Security Compliance requirement Allowable Costs/Cost Principles - 2 CFR §200.403 and §200.405 Type of Finding Internal Control over Compliance - Significant Deficiency Compliance - Noncompliance Questioned Costs: $10,254 Criteria In accordance with 2 CFR §200.403 and §200.405, costs charged to federal awards must be necessary, reasonable, allocable, and adequately documented. Reimbursen,ents based on estimated costs must be reconciled to actual expenditures, and any unsupported amounts must be excluded from final claims. Condition The City received FEMA reimbursements totaling $99,548 under PW No. 51 (0) and $5,704 under PW No. 34(0). These reimbursements were based on estimated costs submitted to FEMA. However, during the financial statement audit, the following discrepancies were noted: PW No. 51 (0): Claimed: Labor $1,048; Equipment $1.8,811; Materials $76,559; Contract $3;130 - Total $99,548 Documented: Labor $1,048; Equipment $8,874; Materials $78,966; Contract $3, 130-Total $92,018 Unsupported costs: $7,530 PW No. 34(0): Claimed: Labor $2,374; Equipment $3,330 -Total $5,704 Documented: Equipment $2,980 - Total $2,980 Unsupported costs: $2,724 Cause The City did not reconcile estimated FEMA reimbursements to actual expenditures incurred and failed to maintain adequate supporting documentation for all cost categories. Effect The City may have received federal funds in excess of actual eligible expenditures, resulting in potential noncompliance with federal cost principles and risk of disallowed costs. Recommendation The City should implement procedures to ensure all FEMA reimbursements are supported by actual, documented expenditures. Management should review the unsupported amounts and consult with FEMA regarding potential repayment or adjustments. Views of Responsible Officials Management concurs with the finding. The City acknowledges that FEMA reimbursements were based on estimated costs and that documentation for certain categories was incomplete. The City will strengthen its procedures for reconciling estimated reimbursements to actual expenditures and ensure that all future claims are supported by detailed documentation. Staff will receive training on FEMA cost principles and documentation standards, and the City will consult with FEMA regarding resolution of the questioned costs.