Finding Text
2024-042 - Misallocation of Expenditures Across Federal Awards Federal Program 14.228 - Community Development Block Grants Program 23.002 - Appalachian Area Development 90.210 - Delta Regional Authority (not subject to audit under Uniform Guidance) Award Numbers ARC-20698 ARC-20699 CDBG Subgrant: 1137-21-111-PF-01 Federal Agencies U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) U.S. Department of the Treasury (via Appalachian Regional Commission) Delta Regional Authority (DRA) Compliance Requirements Allowable Costs/Cost Principles - 2 CFR §200.403 and §200.405 Internal Controls - 2 CFR §200.303 Type of Finding Internal Control over Compliance - Significant Deficiency Compliance '- Noncompliance Questioned Costs (TABLE) Per 2 CFR §200.403, costs must be necessary, reasonable, and allocable to the federal award. Under §200.405, costs must be assigned to the federal award in accordance with the relative benefits received. Additionally, §200.303 requires the non-federal entity to maintain effective internal control over federal awards to ensure compliance. Condition During testing of 13 disbursements totaling $1,541,660 charged to the above federal programs, 11 invoices were not allocated in accordance with the approved budget percentages. This resulted in over-reimbursements across multiple federal awards. Known Over (Under) Reimbursements by Program and Fiscal Year (TABLE) *ALN 90.210 was not subject to audit under Uniform Guidance. Amounts shown are for context only. Cause The City did not consistently apply approved budget allocation percentages when charging expenditures to federal awards. This resulted in misclassification of costs and excess reimbursement from federal sources. Effect The City received federal reimbursements in excess of allowable amounts under ALNs 14.228 and 23.002. These errors may result in repayment obligations and indicate a broader weakness in internal controls over grant accounting and drawdown procedures. Recommendation We recommend the City strengthen its internal controls over grant accounting and reimbursement procedures. This should include: Formal review of allocation schedules prior to submission of reimbursement requests Periodic reconciliation of actual expenditures to approved budget allocations Staff training on federal cost principles and grant compliance requirements Views of Responsible Officials Management concurs with the finding. The City acknowledges that allocation errors occurred across multiple federal programs due to inconsistent application of approved budget percentages. To address this, the City will implement a formal review process for allocation schedules and establish reconciliation procedures to ensure expenditures align with approved budgets. Staff will receive training on federal cost principles and grant compliance requirements. The City will also evaluate prior reimbursements and consult with awarding agencies regarding any necessary adjustments.