Finding 562077 (2024-001)

2024-001 Type of Finding: Material Weakness in Internal Control over Compliance and Material Noncompliance Federal Program Information Funding Agency: U.S. Department of the Treasury Federal ALN: 21.027 Criteria Per 2 CFR 200.214, non-federal entities are prohibited from contracting with parties that are suspended or debarred. 2 CFR 200.318(i) also states that "subrecipients must maintain records sufficient to detail the history of each procurement transaction. These records must include the rationale for the procurement method, contract type selection, contractor selection or rejection, and the basis for the contract price." Condition The Chamber has a procurement policy in place; however, the Chamber neglected to verify if vendors had been suspended or debarred, in accordance with stated regulations. The Chamber also did not maintain sufficient records to document the rationale for the procurement method used for a transaction exceeding the small purchase threshold. Questioned Costs $25,000 Context A sample of 3 vendors was made from a population of 3 vendors whose expenses exceeded the covered transaction threshold that were charged to the major program. Of the 3 sampled vendors, the Chamber neglected to check the suspension or debarment status of 1 vendor prior to entering a covered transaction of $25,000. A sample of 3 vendors was made from a population of 3 vendors whose total transactions exceeded the small purchase threshold. Of the 3 sampled vendors, the Chamber did not maintain sufficient records to document the rationale of using a noncompetitive procurement method for a small purchase transaction. Cause The Chamber claimed that they had been conducting business transactions with this vendor prior to having a procurement policy in place and did not implement the procurement policy on already developed business relationships. The Chamber also did not consider documenting its rationale for continuing to use the vendor for services that exceeded the small purchase threshold that were charged to the major program. Effect Purchases may have occurred that do not follow the policy, and contracts with vendors that had been suspended or debarred could have been awarded and not detected. The Chamber also did not conduct procurement transaction "in a manner that provides full and open competition," as defined in 2 CFR 200.319(a). Repeat Finding Yes - reference 2023-001. Auditor's Recommendations Tacoma-Pierce County Chamber of Commerce should include a provision in all contracts transacted in conjunction with using funds originating from a federal award grant, with respect to suspension and debarment, communicate all requirements for procurement to staff and establish procedures to verify that vendors are not suspended or debarred. Chamber staff should also perform an independent status check of vendors in sam.gov prior to entering into an agreement and retain the search results. The Chamber should also evaluate its current method of procurement and educate staff that if using funds from a federal award to enter into a transaction exceeding the small purchase threshold, that full and open competition must be facilitated, despite any prior relationships with vendors.