Finding 1237597 (2025-001)

Material Weakness Repeat Finding
Requirement
N
Questioned Costs
-
Year
2025
Accepted
2026-09-28

AI Summary

  • Core Issue: Incomplete or unsupported tenant inspection documentation for HOME-assisted rental housing.
  • Impacted Requirements: Lack of evidence that inspections were completed on time and that repairs for failed inspections were made.
  • Recommended Follow-Up: Establish a centralized tracking system for inspections and repairs to ensure compliance and proper documentation.

Finding Text

Finding 2025-001 - Incomplete or Unsupported Tenant Inspection Documentation. Criteria – Recipients administering HOME-assisted rental housing are required to maintain documentation sufficient to demonstrate compliance with applicable program requirements, including applicable property condition, inspection, and record retention requirements. Tenant files and related program records should support that required inspections were completed timely and that any failed inspection items were corrected, as applicable. Condition – During our review of tenant files of two projects, wholly owned by PPL, we noted that the inspection documentation was not consistently maintained or did not demonstrate that required inspections and related repairs were completed. Questioned costs and how they were computed – No questioned costs identified. Context – Three of Five tenant files did not maintain unit inspections or demonstrate that failed inspections items were repaired. Cause – Prior to May 2025, Management did not have an internal compliance department, and the property management department was still experiencing high turnover as it made significant leadership changes to normalize operations and began standardizing operations. Compliance was managed externally by a third-party agency, which caused inspections to be handled in a digital format and many physical files were not properly filed, leading to file misplacement, errors, and in some cases loss of documentation. Effect – Because inspection documentation was incomplete or unavailable, the auditee could not fully support that the sampled units met applicable program inspection or property condition requirements at move-in and/or during 2025. In addition, for the tenant who failed the move-in inspection, the absence of evidence that repairs were completed prevents verification that identified deficiencies were corrected. Identification of Repeat Finding – No. Recommendation 2025-001 – We recommend that management strengthen controls over tenant inspection documentation and corrective action tracking for HOME-assisted units. Specifically, management should: implement a centralized inspection tracking process to monitor required move-in inspections, annual or periodic inspections, failed inspection results, required repairs, repair completion dates, and supporting evidence. Auditee’s comments and response – Management agrees with the finding and is in the process of standardizing procedures to monitor unit inspections and repairs done for failed inspections. Responsible party for corrective action: Haeyoon Fry, Director of Compliance & Operations

Corrective Action Plan

Prior to May, 2025, Management did not have an internal compliance department and the property managemen t department was still experiencing high turnover as it made signi􀀁cant leadership changes to normalize operations and begin standardizing operations. Compliance was managed externally by a third-party partner named Townehousing Compliance. This meant that the new move-ins and applications were handled in a digital format, without an in-person team, and many physical 􀀁les were not properly digitized leading to 􀀁le misplacement, errors, and in some cases loss of documentation. Throughout 2025, the compliance department hired 9 internal team members, including 2 managers and a director. This late running start means that PY2025 is still incomplete as a result of timing. Standardizing, training, and ensuring there is a process around all tenant documentation was part of a year-long training initiative and as of September 2026 there are still portions of the plan being enacted and taught throughout the organization. Saving, backing up, and documenting inspection forms from their various sources is part of this 􀀁nal push in training. As inspection forms are done internally, by service partners, and through the county or city there are many formats to look for and identify – training a property management department of 60+ people on the proper handling and securing of documents has been an undertaking that is still taking shape. Proposed Corrective Plan Going Forward: Management will standardize the move-in inspection forms for HOME-assisted units and train all property managers to scan and save digitized versions of the documents into the Yardi database. All physical 􀀁les are being updated to include a table of content and an area for saving inspection and inspection-related correspondence forms. Inspections and their types will be listed along with 􀀁le requirements and compliance team members will check that they are in the 􀀁le and also attached in Yardi as they process move-ins. Management will have a supervisory review completed on a quarterly basis, led by the Director of Compliance, and a selection of 􀀁les will be reviewed for their content, including the correct inspection form and notes on the type of inspections and their frequency that the unit requires. This plan is already in action and will continue throughout the rest of 2026. December 2026 –All 􀀁les have been brought to the administration building from over 25 separate sites.March 2027 –Past resident 􀀁les have been archived and current resident 􀀁les have been reviewed, digitized, and placed into new folders and added to a directory . September 2027 –Work is expected to be completed on a full overhaul of all past 􀀁les (effective dates before May 2025) and current 􀀁les are being checked more rigorously by an internal department. Proposed Result: Into 2027 and beyond, management expects that the time and investment it has made into 􀀁le retention and compliance will result in quicker responses to audits, lack of missing documentation, and more complete audit responses.

Categories

No categories assigned yet.

Other Findings in this Audit

  • 1237595 2025-001
    Material Weakness Repeat
  • 1237596 2025-001
    Material Weakness Repeat

Programs in Audit

ALN Program Name Expenditures
14.218 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANTS/ENTITLEMENT GRANTS $625,000
93.558 TEMPORARY ASSISTANCE FOR NEEDY FAMILIES $581,661
17.258 WIOA ADULT PROGRAM $374,456
14.239 HOME INVESTMENT PARTNERSHIPS PROGRAM $300,000
14.267 CONTINUUM OF CARE PROGRAM $199,631
17.259 WIOA YOUTH ACTIVITIES $105,236
14.169 HOUSING COUNSELING ASSISTANCE PROGRAM $94,921
21.027 CORONAVIRUS STATE AND LOCAL FISCAL RECOVERY FUNDS $84,327
14.252 SECTION 4 CAPACITY BUILDING FOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING $80,000
10.579 CHILD NUTRITION DISCRETIONARY GRANTS LIMITED AVAILABILITY $5,144