Unsupported and Improper Timing of MTW Capital Fund Program (CFP) Drawdowns (ALN 14.881)
Condition: During testing of the Moving to Work Demonstration Program - Capital Fund Program, we selected a sample of eight eLOCCS drawdown vouchers for review. Of these, the Authority was unable to provide sufficient supporting documentation to substantiate the eligibility, timing, or purpose of the drawdowns for four vouchers. For another voucher, the Authority could only partially support the amount drawn. These issues reflect a lack of adequate documentation necessary to substantiate the allowability and propriety of the expenditures charged to the CFP grants.
Criteria: Under 2 CFR §200.302(b)(3) and §200.305(b), non-Federal entities must maintain adequate documentation to support all federal fund drawdowns and ensure that funds are drawn only when needed for immediate disbursement. Additionally, under the Moving to Work Demonstration Program (ALN 14.881), participating agencies must adhere to the terms of their HUD-approved MTW Agreement, which incorporates applicable requirements of the Uniform Guidance, including principles of financial management and internal control. MTW agencies must ensure that drawdowns are supported by actual, timely obligations and expenditures, and must maintain records sufficient to permit the tracing of funds to a level that ensures proper use in accordance with MTW statutory purposes and HUD requirements.
Cause: The Authority lacked sufficient internal controls to ensure that drawdowns were properly documented at the time of request and reimbursement requests aligned with immediate, allowable expenditures.
Effect: The lack of supporting documentation for certain voucher draws impairs the audit team's ability to verify the allowability and propriety of the expenditures. This may result in questioned costs, findings of noncompliance with federal requirements, and potential recovery actions by HUD
Questioned Costs: $332,356
Recommendation: The Authority should enhance its internal controls to ensure all voucher draws are fully supported by appropriate documentation, reconciled to actual expenditures, retained in compliance with federal recordkeeping requirements, and that unsupported draws are reviewed for potential corrective actions, including reimbursement to HUD if warranted.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: The Authority will implement a process requiring that all MTW Capital Fund drawdown requests be accompanied by complete supporting documentation. Each request will be reviewed for eligibility and compliance with “just-in-time” funding requirements prior to approval by the Executive Director.
Missing Required Moving to Work (MTW) Demonstration Program Documentation (ALN 14.881)
Condition: During our review of the Authority's administration of the MTW Program, the Authority was unable to provide a copy of its Annual Contributions Contract (ACC), which serves as the foundational agreement between the Authority and HUD for the receipt and use of federal funds.
Criteria: Under 2 CFR §200.302 and §200.334, non-Federal entities must maintain effective control over and access to records that support compliance with federal program requirements. The MTW Operations Notice (85 FR 10232) and the Authority's MTW ACC Amendment require that the PHA maintain and certify compliance with its MTW Plan and statutory objectives. The ACC establishes the legal basis for receiving and administering MTW-related federal funds.
Cause: The Authority did not have adequate internal procedures to ensure that foundational program documents were retained, tracked, and made available for audit and oversight purposes.
Effect: The absence of the Annual Contributions Contract (ACC) impairs verification of the Authority's legal authority to receive and administer HUD funds under the MTW program and may result in HUD compliance findings, delayed approvals, or other administrative sanctions.
Questioned Costs: None
Recommendation: The Authority should obtain and retain a copy of its executed ACC for audit and HUD monitoring purposes and establish or strengthen internal controls to track and retain all required MTW program records and certifications in accordance with HUD guidance and federal record retention requirements.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: To address missing foundational documentation, the Authority will locate and archive its Annual Contributions Contract (ACC), the required supplement to the annual MTW Plan, the HUD-issued approval letter for the supplement, and complete the MTW Certification of Compliance for the most recent fiscal year.
Incomplete Tenant File Documentation and Inconsistencies in MTW Housing Assistance and Public Housing Records (ALN 14.881)
Condition: During tenant file testing for both the Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) and Public Housing (PH), components of the Moving to Work (MTW) Demonstration Program, we identified multiple deficiencies in the Authority’s documentation and reporting practices:1. For six out of sixteen HCV tenants, the Authority was unable to provide the tenant file for review.
2. Among the files that were available, several lacked required documentation for the required period to support continued occupancy, rent adjustments, reexaminations, income verification, and inspections.
3. Additionally, variances were noted between the amounts reported on HUD Form 50058 and the actual HAP/UAP disbursements made.Criteria: Under the MTW Operations Notice (85 FR 10232), 2 CFR §200.302, and HUD regulations at 24 CFR §982, public housing authorities must maintain complete and accurate tenant files and ensure that all disbursements are supported by appropriate documentation. HUD Form 50058 must accurately reflect the tenant’s eligibility and payment information, and all payments must be consistent with the amounts authorized and documented in the tenant file.
Cause: The Authority lacked effective internal controls and monitoring procedures over tenant file documentation, rent calculation, inspection recordkeeping, and HUD form completion and retention.
Effect: Incomplete tenant files and discrepancies between reported and actual disbursements impair the Authority’s ability to demonstrate compliance with HUD requirements. These issues increase the risk of improper payments, audit findings, and potential administrative sanctions.
Questioned Costs: $462,754
Recommendation: The Authority should strengthen its internal controls over tenant file maintenance and disbursement reconciliation. All tenant files should be reviewed for completeness, and missing documentation should be obtained. Disbursements should be reconciled to HUD Form 50058 and verified against supporting documentation. Staff should receive training on documentation and compliance requirements under the MTW HAP program, and periodic quality control reviews should be implemented to ensure ongoing compliance.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: The Authority will implement a process to improve tenant file management, ensure complete documentation for occupancy and eligibility, and reconcile disbursement variances with HUD Form 50058 to strengthen compliance with MTW Housing Assistance Payment requirements.
Missing Receipt Support for MTW Public Housing Tenant Transactions (ALN 14.881)
Condition: A review of tenant files under the Moving to Work (MTW) Public Housing program found that while the tenant files themselves were complete, the Authority did not provide supporting documentation for certain rent receipts. In several instances, the rent amounts recorded in the receipt or rent register did not agree with the amounts reported on HUD Form 50058, and no receipt documentation was available to reconcile the difference.
Criteria: Under the MTW Operations Notice (85 FR 10232), 2 CFR §200.302, and HUD regulations at 24 CFR §960, public housing authorities must maintain complete and accurate records that support rent calculations, payments, and tenant eligibility. HUD Form 50058 must accurately reflect tenant rent obligations, and all payments must be properly documented and reconciled.
Cause: The Authority did not maintain adequate documentation to support rent receipts and reconcile them with HUD Form 50058 data.
Effect: The absence of receipt documentation impairs the Authority’s ability to demonstrate compliance with HUD requirements and increases the risk of rent misstatements, audit findings, and potential administrative sanctions.
Questioned Costs: $125,170
Recommendation: The Authority should implement procedures to ensure all rent receipts are supported by appropriate documentation and reconciled to HUD Form 50058, provide staff training on documentation and recordkeeping requirements, and conduct periodic internal reviews of tenant files to verify that all payment records are complete and accurate.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: To address missing rent receipt documentation and inconsistencies with HUD Form 50058, the Authority will implement procedures to improve tenant file management, ensure all receipts are properly documented, and reconcile rent records to support accurate reporting and compliance.
Unsupported and Improper Timing of MTW Capital Fund Program (CFP) Drawdowns (ALN 14.881)
Condition: During testing of the Moving to Work Demonstration Program - Capital Fund Program, we selected a sample of eight eLOCCS drawdown vouchers for review. Of these, the Authority was unable to provide sufficient supporting documentation to substantiate the eligibility, timing, or purpose of the drawdowns for four vouchers. For another voucher, the Authority could only partially support the amount drawn. These issues reflect a lack of adequate documentation necessary to substantiate the allowability and propriety of the expenditures charged to the CFP grants.
Criteria: Under 2 CFR §200.302(b)(3) and §200.305(b), non-Federal entities must maintain adequate documentation to support all federal fund drawdowns and ensure that funds are drawn only when needed for immediate disbursement. Additionally, under the Moving to Work Demonstration Program (ALN 14.881), participating agencies must adhere to the terms of their HUD-approved MTW Agreement, which incorporates applicable requirements of the Uniform Guidance, including principles of financial management and internal control. MTW agencies must ensure that drawdowns are supported by actual, timely obligations and expenditures, and must maintain records sufficient to permit the tracing of funds to a level that ensures proper use in accordance with MTW statutory purposes and HUD requirements.
Cause: The Authority lacked sufficient internal controls to ensure that drawdowns were properly documented at the time of request and reimbursement requests aligned with immediate, allowable expenditures.
Effect: The lack of supporting documentation for certain voucher draws impairs the audit team's ability to verify the allowability and propriety of the expenditures. This may result in questioned costs, findings of noncompliance with federal requirements, and potential recovery actions by HUD
Questioned Costs: $332,356
Recommendation: The Authority should enhance its internal controls to ensure all voucher draws are fully supported by appropriate documentation, reconciled to actual expenditures, retained in compliance with federal recordkeeping requirements, and that unsupported draws are reviewed for potential corrective actions, including reimbursement to HUD if warranted.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: The Authority will implement a process requiring that all MTW Capital Fund drawdown requests be accompanied by complete supporting documentation. Each request will be reviewed for eligibility and compliance with “just-in-time” funding requirements prior to approval by the Executive Director.
Missing Required Moving to Work (MTW) Demonstration Program Documentation (ALN 14.881)
Condition: During our review of the Authority's administration of the MTW Program, the Authority was unable to provide a copy of its Annual Contributions Contract (ACC), which serves as the foundational agreement between the Authority and HUD for the receipt and use of federal funds.
Criteria: Under 2 CFR §200.302 and §200.334, non-Federal entities must maintain effective control over and access to records that support compliance with federal program requirements. The MTW Operations Notice (85 FR 10232) and the Authority's MTW ACC Amendment require that the PHA maintain and certify compliance with its MTW Plan and statutory objectives. The ACC establishes the legal basis for receiving and administering MTW-related federal funds.
Cause: The Authority did not have adequate internal procedures to ensure that foundational program documents were retained, tracked, and made available for audit and oversight purposes.
Effect: The absence of the Annual Contributions Contract (ACC) impairs verification of the Authority's legal authority to receive and administer HUD funds under the MTW program and may result in HUD compliance findings, delayed approvals, or other administrative sanctions.
Questioned Costs: None
Recommendation: The Authority should obtain and retain a copy of its executed ACC for audit and HUD monitoring purposes and establish or strengthen internal controls to track and retain all required MTW program records and certifications in accordance with HUD guidance and federal record retention requirements.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: To address missing foundational documentation, the Authority will locate and archive its Annual Contributions Contract (ACC), the required supplement to the annual MTW Plan, the HUD-issued approval letter for the supplement, and complete the MTW Certification of Compliance for the most recent fiscal year.
Incomplete Tenant File Documentation and Inconsistencies in MTW Housing Assistance and Public Housing Records (ALN 14.881)
Condition: During tenant file testing for both the Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) and Public Housing (PH), components of the Moving to Work (MTW) Demonstration Program, we identified multiple deficiencies in the Authority’s documentation and reporting practices:1. For six out of sixteen HCV tenants, the Authority was unable to provide the tenant file for review.
2. Among the files that were available, several lacked required documentation for the required period to support continued occupancy, rent adjustments, reexaminations, income verification, and inspections.
3. Additionally, variances were noted between the amounts reported on HUD Form 50058 and the actual HAP/UAP disbursements made.Criteria: Under the MTW Operations Notice (85 FR 10232), 2 CFR §200.302, and HUD regulations at 24 CFR §982, public housing authorities must maintain complete and accurate tenant files and ensure that all disbursements are supported by appropriate documentation. HUD Form 50058 must accurately reflect the tenant’s eligibility and payment information, and all payments must be consistent with the amounts authorized and documented in the tenant file.
Cause: The Authority lacked effective internal controls and monitoring procedures over tenant file documentation, rent calculation, inspection recordkeeping, and HUD form completion and retention.
Effect: Incomplete tenant files and discrepancies between reported and actual disbursements impair the Authority’s ability to demonstrate compliance with HUD requirements. These issues increase the risk of improper payments, audit findings, and potential administrative sanctions.
Questioned Costs: $462,754
Recommendation: The Authority should strengthen its internal controls over tenant file maintenance and disbursement reconciliation. All tenant files should be reviewed for completeness, and missing documentation should be obtained. Disbursements should be reconciled to HUD Form 50058 and verified against supporting documentation. Staff should receive training on documentation and compliance requirements under the MTW HAP program, and periodic quality control reviews should be implemented to ensure ongoing compliance.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: The Authority will implement a process to improve tenant file management, ensure complete documentation for occupancy and eligibility, and reconcile disbursement variances with HUD Form 50058 to strengthen compliance with MTW Housing Assistance Payment requirements.
Missing Receipt Support for MTW Public Housing Tenant Transactions (ALN 14.881)
Condition: A review of tenant files under the Moving to Work (MTW) Public Housing program found that while the tenant files themselves were complete, the Authority did not provide supporting documentation for certain rent receipts. In several instances, the rent amounts recorded in the receipt or rent register did not agree with the amounts reported on HUD Form 50058, and no receipt documentation was available to reconcile the difference.
Criteria: Under the MTW Operations Notice (85 FR 10232), 2 CFR §200.302, and HUD regulations at 24 CFR §960, public housing authorities must maintain complete and accurate records that support rent calculations, payments, and tenant eligibility. HUD Form 50058 must accurately reflect tenant rent obligations, and all payments must be properly documented and reconciled.
Cause: The Authority did not maintain adequate documentation to support rent receipts and reconcile them with HUD Form 50058 data.
Effect: The absence of receipt documentation impairs the Authority’s ability to demonstrate compliance with HUD requirements and increases the risk of rent misstatements, audit findings, and potential administrative sanctions.
Questioned Costs: $125,170
Recommendation: The Authority should implement procedures to ensure all rent receipts are supported by appropriate documentation and reconciled to HUD Form 50058, provide staff training on documentation and recordkeeping requirements, and conduct periodic internal reviews of tenant files to verify that all payment records are complete and accurate.
Reply and Corrective Action Plan: To address missing rent receipt documentation and inconsistencies with HUD Form 50058, the Authority will implement procedures to improve tenant file management, ensure all receipts are properly documented, and reconcile rent records to support accurate reporting and compliance.