Finding 966819 (2023-102)

Assistance Listings number and name: 10.691 Good Neighbor Authority Award numbers and year: 22-GN-11030400-027, January 14, 2022 through January 14, 2027 Federal agency: U.S. Department of Agriculture Compliance requirements: Procurement Questioned costs: Unknown Condition—Contrary to federal regulations and the County’s policies and procedures, the Flood Control Department (Department) failed to consider price as a selection factor when awarding a single vendor a construction services contract for which the County paid $5,896,715 during the period July 1, 2022 through June 30, 2023, which was 79.8 percent of the federal program’s expenditures. The Department evaluated the 2 bids it received but awarded the contract to the successful vendor based on its professional qualifications without considering price. Instead, the County negotiated the price of the services after the contract was awarded. Effect—There is an increased risk that the County may have overpaid for construction services, limiting the amount of federal program monies available to carry out other program objectives. Further, the Department was unable to demonstrate whether the County could have acquired these services at a lower cost. This finding could potentially affect other federal programs that the Department administers. Cause—County management reported that the Department’s program personnel misunderstood the County’s procurement policies and procedures for procuring services with federal monies, which require them to follow federal Uniform Guidance regulations and consider cost as a factor. They further explained that instead the Department followed Arizona Revised Statutes, which may be used for procuring construction contracts with State and local monies and does not use cost as a factor when selecting a vendor. Finally, the County did not have a designated person assigned to review all County procurements to verify compliance with federal regulations and the County’s policies. Criteria—Federal Uniform Guidance regulations require the County to establish and follow competitive purchasing policies and procedures that align with federal Uniform Guidance procurement standards when acquiring goods and services using federal awards (2 CFR §§200.318 through 200.327). Specifically, these regulations require that the County use a written, fixed-price contract award to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder after considering factors such as discounts, transportation costs, and life cycle costs, and only architectural/engineering services can be procured without considering price as a selection factor (2 CFR §200.320). Further, the County’s policies and procedures require that the County follow Federal Uniform Guidance procurement procedures outlined in 2 CFR §§200 when making purchases with federal monies. Finally, federal regulation requires establishing and maintaining effective internal control over federal awards that provides reasonable assurance that federal programs are being managed in compliance with all applicable laws, regulations, and award terms (2 CFR §200.303). Recommendations—The County should: 1. Monitor departments’ adherence to the County’s policies and procedures for purchasing goods and services using federal awards, including the departments' following Uniform Guidance 2 CFR §§200 requirements to use cost as a selection factor for awarding a construction services contract. 2. Train County departments on federal Uniform Guidance requirements and the County’s procurement policies and procedures ensuring that they understand the policies and procedures to follow when acquiring goods and services using federal awards. 3. Designate an independent person who is knowledgeable about federal requirements and the County’s procurement policies and procedures to review and approve procurements involving federal awards. The County’s corrective action plan at the end of this report includes the views and planned corrective action of its responsible officials. We are not required to audit and have not audited these responses and planned corrective actions and therefore provide no assurances as to their accuracy.