Finding 526113 (2024-001)

Significant Deficiency Repeat Finding
Requirement
P
Questioned Costs
-
Year
2024
Accepted
2025-03-07
Audit: 345207
Organization: Cadence Care Network (OH)
Auditor: Packer Thomas

AI Summary

  • Core Issue: Many general ledger accounts were not reconciled, leading to numerous audit adjustments.
  • Impacted Requirements: Accurate and timely financial statement reconciliation is essential for reliable reporting.
  • Recommended Follow-Up: Implement formal monthly accounting procedures to ensure all significant accounts are reconciled.

Finding Text

Accounts Reconciliation - Statement of Criteria: A sound accounting system requires that the financial statement accounts are recorded and reconciled in an accurate and timely manner. Statement of Condition: A significant number of general ledger accounts were not reconciled to the underlying supporting documentation resulting in a significant number of audit adjustments being made as part of audit procedures. Statement of Cause: Over the last three years the organization has experienced rapid growth and diversification. Most of this growth and diversification occured as our Chief Financial Officer (over 20 years of service) was in the process of retiring and we were in the process of hiring a new one. As a result, the organization lost much institutional memory and found itself focusing on building toward the future. Growth and diversification include: a merge that occured on 7/1/2022 allowing us to gain a footprint in Massillon, Toledo, and Upper Sandusky Ohio, the establishment of a Social Enterprise (Cadence Coffeehouse and Creperie), and the award of the OhioRISE Contract with Aetna. The sheer scale of these operations challenged our financial department and CFO hired to replace our longstanding CFO. This growth can be evidenced by our rapid fiscal growth in both income and assets during the time period. As a result of these shortcomings and this cause, the former CFO is no longer employed at the organization. A new CFO was hired on April 8, 2024. New procedures were implemented quickly upon his hire. Effect: Because of these instances noted above, a significant number of general ledger accounts were not reconciled to the underlying supporting documentation, resulting in a significant number of general ledger accounts being mistated. This led to a significant number of audit adjustments being made. Unreliable general ledger account balances make it more difficult for the governance board to make decisions based on monthly financial statements. Recommendation: Management should formalize monthly accounting and closing procedures to include reconciliation of all significant account balances and to ensure accurate financial reporting information is being maintained by the Organization.

Corrective Action Plan

Recommendation: Management should formalize monthly accounting and closing procedures to include reconciliation of all significant account balances and to ensure accurate financial reporting information is being maintained by the Organization. Action Taken: Management at Cadence Care Network recognizes that there have been shortcomings in the reconciliation processes; however, they have developed and put into action closure and reconciliation schedules. Those processess have now been in place since the new CFO implemented them throughout the last part of 2024. The ongoing audit has established that Cadence Care Network relies excessively on auditors for reconciling accounts and creating schedules. During the leadership transition, it became apparent that the previous CFO lacked the necessary vision and skills to effectively lead the financial department. The shortcomings and inefficiencies of the former administration were only highlighted by the current CFO. With the new CFO in charge, a sense of order and direction has been established, new positions have been created, innovative strategies have been introduced to support growth, and policies have been enforced, and integrated into a short- and long-term plan.

Categories

Reporting

Other Findings in this Audit

  • 1102555 2024-001
    Significant Deficiency Repeat

Programs in Audit

ALN Program Name Expenditures
93.658 Foster Care Title IV-E $1.05M
84.425 Education Stabilization Fund $459,010
93.670 Child Abuse and Neglect Discretionary Activities $100,370