Finding 500116 (2023-002)

Significant Deficiency
Requirement
A
Questioned Costs
-
Year
2023
Accepted
2024-09-30

AI Summary

  • Core Issue: The Authority reported significant interfund receivables and payables, leading to negative cash balances in certain programs, which raises compliance concerns with HUD.
  • Impacted Requirements: Due To/Due From relationships should not be reported under accrual accounting, as resources from one program cannot support another.
  • Recommended Follow-Up: Enhance cash reconciliation controls and ensure interfund balances are repaid monthly to prevent negative cash situations.

Finding Text

Criteria Condition According to PHA Accounting Brief #14 Due To/Due From relationships should not be reported under accrual accounting simply from the result of a PHA using a common checking or working capital account. Because of the basic nature of most Federal and state programs, resources from one program cannot be used to support the costs of another program. HUD views Due To’s and Due From’s reported in a PHA’s Federal programs as possible indicators of non‐compliance. The Authority has interfund receivables and payables that have not been repaid as of fiscal year end. This results in certain programs having a negative cash balance as of fiscal year end. Context The Authority reported a material ($549,444 in total, $496,338 in PHprogram) amount of interfund receivables and payables, which is a significant red flag for HUD reviewers. Cause Effect Recommendations The Authority should expand it's controls over cash reconciliations to include a step to verify if a program, fund or component unit is accurate along with the entire cash pool. Also interfund should be repaid monthly at a minimum. Management agrees with the finding, see Management's Corrective Action Plan. The Authority was not effectively monitoring and managing interfund program balances in order to ensure that programs were not spending funds that they do not have. The use of Due To/ Due From transactions reported in the Authority's financials net to some programs having negative cash balances, which could signify to HUD that one or more programs have used resources to cover the costs of another program.

Corrective Action Plan

Currently the Columbus Housing Authority is responding to your findings as it relates to the fiscal year December 2023. We are addressing the audit findings related to financial statement missed FDS submission deadline for the unaudited financials and the Authority interfund receivables and payables balance that have not been repaid as of the fiscal year end. The following corrective actions will be implemented as it relates to the findings: The following steps will be taken regarding the financial statement FDS submission and interfund repayment: Financial Statements 1. Understand Deadlines: Become familiar with the submission deadlines for both unaudited and audited financial data. 2. Create a Timeline: Develop a detailed timeline that includes all key dates and milestones leading up to the submission deadline. This will include internal review periods and time for corrections. 3. Assign Responsibilities: Clearly define roles and responsibilities within our team to ensure that each part of the submission process is covered. 4. Regular Check-ins: Schedule regular check-ins to monitor progress and address any issues that may arise early on. 5. Use HUD Tools: Utilize HUD’s FDS Submission Upload Tool and other resources to streamline the data entry and submission process. 6. Perform Completeness Checks: Before submitting, perform a submission completeness check to ensure all required data is accurate and complete. 7. Request Extensions if Needed: If we encounter unusual circumstances that may delay our submission, request an extension as early as possible. 8. Backup and Documentation: Keep backups of all submitted data and maintain thorough documentation of the submission process for future reference. Interfund Repayment 1. Identify Interfund Transaction: List all interfund transactions, this includes payables, payroll, reimbursements, and etc. 37 2. Record Transaction: Ensure all interfund transactions are recorded in the general ledger. 3. Reconcile Balances: Reconcile the balances of all interfund accounts between each fund. 4. Investigate Discrepancies: Investigate and resolve any discrepancies found during the reconciliation process. Make the necessary adjusting entries to correct any errors or discrepancies identified. 5. Documentation: Maintain thorough documentation for all interfund transactions. Additionally, regular monitoring and periodic review of the effectiveness of the implemented controls will be conducted to ensure ongoing compliance and continuous improvement.

Categories

HUD Housing Programs Subrecipient Monitoring

Other Findings in this Audit

  • 1076558 2023-002
    Significant Deficiency

Programs in Audit

ALN Program Name Expenditures
14.850 Public Housing Operating Fund $1.71M
14.872 Public Housing Capital Fund $1.11M
84.287 Twenty-First Century Community Learning Centers $606,925
14.870 Resident Opportunity and Supportive Services - Service Coordinators $84,324