Finding 24186 (2022-001)

Significant Deficiency
Requirement
P
Questioned Costs
-
Year
2022
Accepted
2023-07-25

AI Summary

  • Issue: A potential conflict of interest was not disclosed on time, violating grant requirements.
  • Requirements Impacted: The Organization failed to disclose conflicts as mandated by the grant, leading to non-compliance.
  • Recommended Follow-Up: Implement immediate conflict of interest disclosures for board members upon appointment, in addition to annual reviews.

Finding Text

Potential Conflict of Interest not Disclosed Timely- ALN 11.307- Economic Adjustment Assistance Criteria The control deficiency exists as the Corporation did not disclose a potential conflict of interest, as required b the grant, to the U.S. Department of Commerce when it arose. Condition A board member of the Organization, appointed by a local governmental entity, was a party to a consulting contract with that governmental entity regarding issues surrounding the Department of Commerce grant, with work commencing in August 2019. The board member was also employed by a vendor which the Organization used to expend grant funds. The grant states that all potential conflicts of interest are required to be disclosed in writing; this potential conflict was not disclosed until more than a year into utilization of the grant. The disclosure occurred subsequent to June 30, 2022, as soon as it was noted by the Organization. Cause The Organization did not have in place a standing requirement to have a complete conflict of interest disclosure written and signed by each board member immediately upon appointment or election to the Board, which would have brought the matter to light immediately. Instead, each member of the Board signs a conflict of interest disclosure annually, usually at the first Board meeting of the fiscal year. Effect The Organization was not in compliance with grant requirements regarding disclosure of potential conflicts of interest. The Organization complied with this requirement as soon as the potential conflict was noted. Context The Organization had an internal conflict of interest policy but did not have controls in place which ensured its completeness and utilization. Recommendation It is our recommendation that the Organization require each Board member to write and sign a document that indicates any potential conflicts of interest immediately upon appointment or election to the Board in addition to the annual disclosure, which is then reviewed by the CEO. This control allows the CEO to continually be aware of any potential conflicts of interest and act accordingly. Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions See Exhibit I.

Corrective Action Plan

2022-001- Potential Conflict of Interest not Disclosed Timely- ALN 11.307- Economic Adjustment Assistance. Condition- a board member of the Organization, appointed by a local governmental entity. was a party to a consulting contract with that governmental entity regarding issues surrounding the Department of Commerce grant, with work commencing in August 2019. The board member was also employed by a vendor which the Organization used to expend grant funds. The grant states that all potential conflicts of interest are required to be disclosed in writing; this potential conflict was not disclosed until more than a year into utilization of the grant. The disclosure occurred subsequent to June 30, 2022, as soon as it was noted by the Organization. Corrective Action Planned: 1. The Organization Conflict of Interest Policy will be presented to the board at the beginning of each fiscal year for review, approval and signature of each board member. 2. When a new board member is seated the Organization Conflict of Interest Policy will be presented to the new board member at the orientation session for review, approval and signature. The activities outlined are ongoing and currently being implemented. Phil Christopherson, CEO, can be contacted for further information.

Categories

Procurement, Suspension & Debarment Internal Control / Segregation of Duties

Other Findings in this Audit

  • 600628 2022-001
    Significant Deficiency

Programs in Audit

ALN Program Name Expenditures
11.307 Economic Adjustment Assistance $850,370