Finding 1162014 (2024-008)

Material Weakness Repeat Finding
Requirement
E
Questioned Costs
$1
Year
2024
Accepted
2025-11-06
Audit: 371876
Organization: Bill Wilson Center (CA)
Auditor: CBIZ CPAS PC

AI Summary

  • Core Issue: Management failed to consistently monitor and document participant eligibility for the Crime Victim Assistance program, affecting compliance.
  • Impacted Requirements: Inadequate review of costs and activities against eligible participants led to unsupported financial statements and potential questioned costs of $17,562.
  • Recommended Follow-Up: Implement a system for organizing eligibility documents, create eligibility templates, enhance billing review processes, and provide training for staff.

Finding Text

IDENTIFICATION OF THE FEDERAL PROGRAM ALN 16.575 Crime Victim Assistance CRITERIA An eligible participant in this program is an individuals aged 18 to 25. CONDITION Management was not able to provide support for all of the participants tested. Accordingly, we were not able to determine eligibility. CAUSE Management did not monitor eligibility on a consistent basis and maintain appropriate supporting documentation to support participant eligibility. The costs and activity were not properly reviewed against eligible participants or the billing to grantors was not reviewed. Accurate and timely monthly grant billing procedures were not performed. EFFECT Certain key financial statement amounts are not supported. The inability to produce documents could lead to questioned costs or produce inconsistent results which could impact the ability to receive future funding. QUESTION COSTS $17,562. RECOMMENDATION Management should develop a system to store and categorize electronic and paper documents so that they can be easily accessible. Management should create a template of the eligibility requirements for each grant. As part of the grant billing process, management should review the billing support for eligible participants and costs. More care is required to be exercised when reviewing eligibility and costs charged on grants. Training should be provided to program and accounting staff. SECTION III - FEDERAL AWARD FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS (CONTINUED) MATERIAL WEAKNESS COMPLIANCE 2024-008 – ELIGIBILITY (CONTINUED) MANAGEMENT’S RESPONSE AND PLANNED CORRECTIVE ACTION See attached corrective action plan.

Corrective Action Plan

For ALN 16.575 Crime Victim Assistance There was a staffing change for the program after FY23-24. Since the new Program Manager joined in December 2023, she worked with her team to put together the following procedures and protocols: For direct program expenses, all copies of rent payment requests, check stubs and client signed half sheets are retained. Client support purchases have original receipts. For proof of client eligibility, the previous management team kept the files in paper format. The new management team saved all the copies of client IDs, birth certificates or passports in AWARDS to verify age of participants. Client agreements are saved electronically in AWARDS. Paper copies are stored in locked cabinets as well. All time entries are reviewed, approved, submitted, processed and saved in Paycom.

Categories

Questioned Costs Eligibility Material Weakness

Other Findings in this Audit

  • 1162013 2024-007
    Material Weakness Repeat

Programs in Audit

ALN Program Name Expenditures
93.658 Foster Care Title IV-E, AFDC-FC - THP-Non Minor Dependent (0268.18.01), passed through the County of Santa Clara $856,508
14.218 CDBG Enclave Renovation Project (6/30/24), passed through the City of San Jose $773,014
93.674 John H. Chafee Foster Care Program for Successful Transition to Adulthood, passed through the County of Santa Clara $717,224
14.276 Rapid Rehousing Program (12/31/2024) $667,898
14.267 Rapid ReHousing for Homeless Youth, passed through County of Santa Clara Office of Supportive Housing $518,250
21.027 Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds, Emergency Housing Voucher Program, passed through County of Santa Clara $502,060
14.267 Transitional Housing for YYF South County (ends 3/31/2024) $405,471
14.267 Rapid ReHousing for Youth (ends 11/30/2023) $315,043
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Specialized Emergency Housing Program (ends 9/30/2024), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $251,117
14.267 Transitional Housing to Rapid Rehousing for Youth (ends 11/30/2024) $209,797
93.623 Basic Center Grant, RHY- Basic Center Grant - South County (ends 9/29/24) $180,658
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Tranistional Housing Program (ends 12/31/2023), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $169,728
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Marginalized Victimss Program (ends12/31/2023), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $169,098
93.788 State Opioid Response Grant (SOR III), passed through Sierra Health Foundation $164,255
14.267 Transitional Housing for YYF South County (ends 3/31/2025) $156,541
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Tranistional Housing Program (ends 12/31/2024), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $156,202
93.623 Basic Center Grant, RHY- Basic Center Grant - North County (ends 9/29/24) $155,033
14.267 Peacock Commons - Permanent Housing (ends 11/30/24) $122,479
93.550 Transitional Living for Homless Youth - Maternity Group Home (ends 9/29/24) $109,933
14.267 Peacock Commons - Permanent Housing (ends 11/30/23) $103,080
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Homeless Youth and Exploitation Program (ends 6/30/2024), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $97,068
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Child Abuse Treatment Program (ends 12/31/2023), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $97,000
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Child Abuse Treatment Program (ends 12/31/2024), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $87,939
93.557 Street Outreach Program (ends 9/29/2024) $86,303
14.267 Transitional Housing for YYF North County (ends 11/30/2023) $81,691
14.267 Transitional Housing to Rapid Rehousing for Youth (ends 11/30/2023) $79,619
16.575 Crime Victim Assistance, VOCA - Specialized Emergency Housing Program (ends 9/30/2023), passed through California Office of Emergency Services $72,257
14.276 Santa Cruz Shared Housing Program (12/31/2024) $69,608
14.276 Santa Cruz Shared Housing Program (12/31/2023) $61,660
93.550 Transitional Living for Homless Youth - Maternity Group Home (ends 9/29/23) $52,219
93.623 Basic Center Grant, RHY- Basic Center Grant - South County (ends 9/29/23) $48,592
93.623 Basic Center Grant, RHY- Basic Center Grant - North County (ends 9/29/23) $43,823
14.218 CDBG Family Therapy and School Outreach Program, passed through the City of Santa Clara $30,000
14.218 CDBG Family and Individual Counseling Services Program, passed through the City of Sunnyvale $25,000
93.557 Street Outreach Program (ends 9/29/2023) $24,371
97.024 Federal Emergency Food and Shelter Board Program - Phase 41 (to 12/31/2024) $17,000
14.218 CDBG Family Advocacy Services Program (to 12/31/2023), passed through the City of Mountain View $3,535