CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Federal Award Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment # 2021-005
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER DISBURSEMENTS OF
FEDERAL FUNDS MUST BE IMPROVED
HEAD START AND EARLY HEAD START PROGRAMS
Federal Assistance Listing # 93.600
(Questioned Costs - Undetermined)
Condition:
In connection with audit of the Authority, we performed risk assessment of the Authority’s significant financial
transactions, material account balances, and other significant risk areas and each applicable relevant assertion of each area, and we designed and perform substantive procedures and test of internal controls to determine what level of reliance that could be placed on the system of internal control of the Authority. Using auditor’s judgment, we selected various transactions for testings the system of internal control and the appropriateness and reasonableness of the expenditures. During our audit, we performed the following procedures:
We selected twenty- five (25) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respects to the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs:
1. There were fifteen (15) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders to
support the disbursements.
2 Four (4) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were fourteen (14) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement
policies and procedures of the Authority.
4. There was one (1) transaction for the purchase of a truck that was not in agreement with bid
documentation provided by the Authority. Further, we noted no specific authorization of such
transaction in the notice of award for the purchase during the budget period of the acquisition.
We selected fifteen (15) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respect to the indirect cost pool:
1. There were fourteen (14) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders
to support the disbursements.
2 Two (2) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were one (1) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement policies
and procedures of the Authority.
The aforementioned exceptions were not resolved as of the date the audit report, September 8, 2023.
Context:
We selected 25 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs.
We selected 15 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the indirect cost pool
Criteria:
Internal policy of the Authority, generally accepted accounting principles, Government Auditing Standards and the Uniform Guidance.
The non-Federal entity must have and use documented procurement procedures, consistent with State, local, and tribal laws and regulations and the standards of the Uniform Guidance (UG), 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards for the acquisition of property or services required under a Federal award or subaward. The non-Federal entity's documented procurement procedures must conform to the procurement standards identified in 2 CFR §200.317 through 200.327.
Effect:
The transaction could result in cost not allowed under federal and state regulations and the provisions of the grant agreement.
Cause:
The failure of the Authority to follow its written procurement policies and procedures and to update the existing
procedures to conform to federal and state laws. Management and the board of directors must have proper oversight and governance of the purchase and procurement procedures.
Recommendation:
We recommend that the board of directors and management immediately review all the transactions outlined in this finding and determine if the exceptions noted can be resolved and corrected. Further action should be taken to prevent, eliminate and properly remediate other exceptions similar in nature as those described in this finding. Policies and procedures should be reviewed and updated to conform to 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards. The Authority should add additional staff with the proper accounting skills, knowledge and experience with grant accounting.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and takes exception to several of the items listed. For example, some of the transactions listed that were missing check requests (both Head Start/Early Head Start and Indirect Cost Pool) were for monthly expenditures like utility bills, insurance, rent and other contractual obligations. Management has not in the past issued a check request each month for these transactions as they are part of the ongoing operation of the programs listed.
Transactions listed with only one signature occurred as an oversight as the banking authority only requires one signature while our policy may indicate two signatures. Management feels the purchase of the truck was procured in agreement with approvals from the funding agency and board as required. Proper documentation was provided and is currently available for further review. Management continues to follow the proper guidelines regarding procurement and purchases related to the policies and procedures of the agency as well as micro purchase guidelines set forth by the Federal awarding agency. The Board of Directors also approved a revision to the policies and procedures requiring two “live” signatures on all checks issued by the agency. There is also an ongoing review of the current policies and procedures and recommendations for changes and updates are forthcoming. Management reserves the right for further review of these findings with the audit firm for additional documentation and resolution.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Federal Award Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment # 2021-005
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER DISBURSEMENTS OF
FEDERAL FUNDS MUST BE IMPROVED
HEAD START AND EARLY HEAD START PROGRAMS
Federal Assistance Listing # 93.600
(Questioned Costs - Undetermined)
Condition:
In connection with audit of the Authority, we performed risk assessment of the Authority’s significant financial
transactions, material account balances, and other significant risk areas and each applicable relevant assertion of each area, and we designed and perform substantive procedures and test of internal controls to determine what level of reliance that could be placed on the system of internal control of the Authority. Using auditor’s judgment, we selected various transactions for testings the system of internal control and the appropriateness and reasonableness of the expenditures. During our audit, we performed the following procedures:
We selected twenty- five (25) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respects to the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs:
1. There were fifteen (15) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders to
support the disbursements.
2 Four (4) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were fourteen (14) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement
policies and procedures of the Authority.
4. There was one (1) transaction for the purchase of a truck that was not in agreement with bid
documentation provided by the Authority. Further, we noted no specific authorization of such
transaction in the notice of award for the purchase during the budget period of the acquisition.
We selected fifteen (15) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respect to the indirect cost pool:
1. There were fourteen (14) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders
to support the disbursements.
2 Two (2) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were one (1) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement policies
and procedures of the Authority.
The aforementioned exceptions were not resolved as of the date the audit report, September 8, 2023.
Context:
We selected 25 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs.
We selected 15 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the indirect cost pool
Criteria:
Internal policy of the Authority, generally accepted accounting principles, Government Auditing Standards and the Uniform Guidance.
The non-Federal entity must have and use documented procurement procedures, consistent with State, local, and tribal laws and regulations and the standards of the Uniform Guidance (UG), 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards for the acquisition of property or services required under a Federal award or subaward. The non-Federal entity's documented procurement procedures must conform to the procurement standards identified in 2 CFR §200.317 through 200.327.
Effect:
The transaction could result in cost not allowed under federal and state regulations and the provisions of the grant agreement.
Cause:
The failure of the Authority to follow its written procurement policies and procedures and to update the existing
procedures to conform to federal and state laws. Management and the board of directors must have proper oversight and governance of the purchase and procurement procedures.
Recommendation:
We recommend that the board of directors and management immediately review all the transactions outlined in this finding and determine if the exceptions noted can be resolved and corrected. Further action should be taken to prevent, eliminate and properly remediate other exceptions similar in nature as those described in this finding. Policies and procedures should be reviewed and updated to conform to 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards. The Authority should add additional staff with the proper accounting skills, knowledge and experience with grant accounting.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and takes exception to several of the items listed. For example, some of the transactions listed that were missing check requests (both Head Start/Early Head Start and Indirect Cost Pool) were for monthly expenditures like utility bills, insurance, rent and other contractual obligations. Management has not in the past issued a check request each month for these transactions as they are part of the ongoing operation of the programs listed.
Transactions listed with only one signature occurred as an oversight as the banking authority only requires one signature while our policy may indicate two signatures. Management feels the purchase of the truck was procured in agreement with approvals from the funding agency and board as required. Proper documentation was provided and is currently available for further review. Management continues to follow the proper guidelines regarding procurement and purchases related to the policies and procedures of the agency as well as micro purchase guidelines set forth by the Federal awarding agency. The Board of Directors also approved a revision to the policies and procedures requiring two “live” signatures on all checks issued by the agency. There is also an ongoing review of the current policies and procedures and recommendations for changes and updates are forthcoming. Management reserves the right for further review of these findings with the audit firm for additional documentation and resolution.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Federal Award Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment # 2021-006
THE AUTHORITY SHOULD ESTABLISH FORMAL POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR OBTAINING,
RECORDING, AND REPORTING NON-FEDERAL MATCH
HEAD START AND EARLY HEAD START PROGRAMS
Federal Assistance Listing # 93.600
(Questioned Costs - Undetermined)
Condition:
During our audit, we noted that the Authority does not have formal policies and procedures developed that address the requirements to obtain, record and report non-federal match as required by the Department of Health and Human Services - Head Start Programs. It is a statutory requirement for grantees to provide such match as specified under the Head Start Act Section 640(b). Administrative requirements are codified in 45 CFR § 75.306 which states in the Act that a grantee agency must provide 20 percent of the total costs of the Head Start program during a budget period unless a waiver has been granted. During the audit of the year ended June 30, 2021, the Authority had grants awards requiring non-federal match (in-kind) as set forth in the notice of awards (NOA); however, the general ledger did not disclose any in-kind recorded or reported that met the requirements of the federal regulations. We did not observe any evidence of non-federal match being obtained, valued and recorded in accordance with generally accepted principles and federal regulations nor were we presented evidence that a responsible official with HHS approved of a wavier (other than a waiver for the CARES Act
funding documented in the NOA.
Context:
We reviewed grants awarded during the audit period to determine the level of funding granted and the required nonfederal match to be provided by the grantee (the Authority).
Criteria:
In accordance with section 640(b) of the Act, federal financial assistance to a grantee will not exceed 80 percent of the approved total program costs. A grantee must contribute 20 percent as non-federal match each budget period. The responsible HHS official may approve a waiver of all or a portion of the non-federal match requirement on the basis of the grantee’s written application submitted for the budget period and any supporting evidence the responsible HHS official requires. In deciding whether to grant a waiver, the responsible HHS official will consider the circumstances specified at section 640(b) of the Act and whether the grantee has made a reasonable effort to comply with the non-federal match requirement. In addition to internal policy of the Authority, generally accepted accounting principles, Government Auditing Standards and the Uniform Guidance.
Effect:
The transaction could result in the Authority refunding funds to HHS for the failure to obtain and report the required nonfederal match.
Cause:
The failure of the Authority to have formal policies and procedures governing the requirements of obtaining, valuing and recording non-federal match as required by federal regulations. Management and the board of directors must have proper oversight and governance over the tracking, valuing and reporting of non-federal match.
Recommendation:
We recommend that the board of directors and management immediately identify all grants and contracts requiring nonfederal match. The types of non-federal match should be gathered from the various sources, valued using accepted methodologies and techniques, recorded for the appropriate period and reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles and federal regulations.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding. The agency has always utilized the Georgia Pre-K reimbursement it receives during the fiscal year as the matching component for Head Start. The total reimbursement for the reporting period was $814,374. While this amount was not recorded in the general ledger as matching, all matching expenditures were recorded in all the SF425 that were submitted to the funding agency. The agency has all the proper documentation for further review related to Non-Federal Share Matching. The agency has all documentation related to this reimbursement as well as prior audit periods where this amount has been utilized and accepted as the matching component.
The agency will move forward with the development of providing proper oversight and governance of tracking and reporting non-federal match.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Federal Award Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment # 2021-005
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER DISBURSEMENTS OF
FEDERAL FUNDS MUST BE IMPROVED
HEAD START AND EARLY HEAD START PROGRAMS
Federal Assistance Listing # 93.600
(Questioned Costs - Undetermined)
Condition:
In connection with audit of the Authority, we performed risk assessment of the Authority’s significant financial
transactions, material account balances, and other significant risk areas and each applicable relevant assertion of each area, and we designed and perform substantive procedures and test of internal controls to determine what level of reliance that could be placed on the system of internal control of the Authority. Using auditor’s judgment, we selected various transactions for testings the system of internal control and the appropriateness and reasonableness of the expenditures. During our audit, we performed the following procedures:
We selected twenty- five (25) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respects to the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs:
1. There were fifteen (15) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders to
support the disbursements.
2 Four (4) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were fourteen (14) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement
policies and procedures of the Authority.
4. There was one (1) transaction for the purchase of a truck that was not in agreement with bid
documentation provided by the Authority. Further, we noted no specific authorization of such
transaction in the notice of award for the purchase during the budget period of the acquisition.
We selected fifteen (15) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respect to the indirect cost pool:
1. There were fourteen (14) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders
to support the disbursements.
2 Two (2) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were one (1) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement policies
and procedures of the Authority.
The aforementioned exceptions were not resolved as of the date the audit report, September 8, 2023.
Context:
We selected 25 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs.
We selected 15 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the indirect cost pool
Criteria:
Internal policy of the Authority, generally accepted accounting principles, Government Auditing Standards and the Uniform Guidance.
The non-Federal entity must have and use documented procurement procedures, consistent with State, local, and tribal laws and regulations and the standards of the Uniform Guidance (UG), 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards for the acquisition of property or services required under a Federal award or subaward. The non-Federal entity's documented procurement procedures must conform to the procurement standards identified in 2 CFR §200.317 through 200.327.
Effect:
The transaction could result in cost not allowed under federal and state regulations and the provisions of the grant agreement.
Cause:
The failure of the Authority to follow its written procurement policies and procedures and to update the existing
procedures to conform to federal and state laws. Management and the board of directors must have proper oversight and governance of the purchase and procurement procedures.
Recommendation:
We recommend that the board of directors and management immediately review all the transactions outlined in this finding and determine if the exceptions noted can be resolved and corrected. Further action should be taken to prevent, eliminate and properly remediate other exceptions similar in nature as those described in this finding. Policies and procedures should be reviewed and updated to conform to 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards. The Authority should add additional staff with the proper accounting skills, knowledge and experience with grant accounting.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and takes exception to several of the items listed. For example, some of the transactions listed that were missing check requests (both Head Start/Early Head Start and Indirect Cost Pool) were for monthly expenditures like utility bills, insurance, rent and other contractual obligations. Management has not in the past issued a check request each month for these transactions as they are part of the ongoing operation of the programs listed.
Transactions listed with only one signature occurred as an oversight as the banking authority only requires one signature while our policy may indicate two signatures. Management feels the purchase of the truck was procured in agreement with approvals from the funding agency and board as required. Proper documentation was provided and is currently available for further review. Management continues to follow the proper guidelines regarding procurement and purchases related to the policies and procedures of the agency as well as micro purchase guidelines set forth by the Federal awarding agency. The Board of Directors also approved a revision to the policies and procedures requiring two “live” signatures on all checks issued by the agency. There is also an ongoing review of the current policies and procedures and recommendations for changes and updates are forthcoming. Management reserves the right for further review of these findings with the audit firm for additional documentation and resolution.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Federal Award Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment # 2021-005
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER DISBURSEMENTS OF
FEDERAL FUNDS MUST BE IMPROVED
HEAD START AND EARLY HEAD START PROGRAMS
Federal Assistance Listing # 93.600
(Questioned Costs - Undetermined)
Condition:
In connection with audit of the Authority, we performed risk assessment of the Authority’s significant financial
transactions, material account balances, and other significant risk areas and each applicable relevant assertion of each area, and we designed and perform substantive procedures and test of internal controls to determine what level of reliance that could be placed on the system of internal control of the Authority. Using auditor’s judgment, we selected various transactions for testings the system of internal control and the appropriateness and reasonableness of the expenditures. During our audit, we performed the following procedures:
We selected twenty- five (25) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respects to the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs:
1. There were fifteen (15) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders to
support the disbursements.
2 Four (4) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were fourteen (14) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement
policies and procedures of the Authority.
4. There was one (1) transaction for the purchase of a truck that was not in agreement with bid
documentation provided by the Authority. Further, we noted no specific authorization of such
transaction in the notice of award for the purchase during the budget period of the acquisition.
We selected fifteen (15) transactions using auditor’s judgement with the following exceptions noted as respect to the indirect cost pool:
1. There were fourteen (14) transactions with missing check request documents and\or purchase orders
to support the disbursements.
2 Two (2) transactions with only one signature on the cancelled checks.
3. There were one (1) transactions missing evidence of support as required by the procurement policies
and procedures of the Authority.
The aforementioned exceptions were not resolved as of the date the audit report, September 8, 2023.
Context:
We selected 25 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the Head Start and Early Head Start Programs.
We selected 15 transactions haphazardly from the disbursement records of the indirect cost pool
Criteria:
Internal policy of the Authority, generally accepted accounting principles, Government Auditing Standards and the Uniform Guidance.
The non-Federal entity must have and use documented procurement procedures, consistent with State, local, and tribal laws and regulations and the standards of the Uniform Guidance (UG), 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards for the acquisition of property or services required under a Federal award or subaward. The non-Federal entity's documented procurement procedures must conform to the procurement standards identified in 2 CFR §200.317 through 200.327.
Effect:
The transaction could result in cost not allowed under federal and state regulations and the provisions of the grant agreement.
Cause:
The failure of the Authority to follow its written procurement policies and procedures and to update the existing
procedures to conform to federal and state laws. Management and the board of directors must have proper oversight and governance of the purchase and procurement procedures.
Recommendation:
We recommend that the board of directors and management immediately review all the transactions outlined in this finding and determine if the exceptions noted can be resolved and corrected. Further action should be taken to prevent, eliminate and properly remediate other exceptions similar in nature as those described in this finding. Policies and procedures should be reviewed and updated to conform to 2 CFR §200.318 General procurement standards. The Authority should add additional staff with the proper accounting skills, knowledge and experience with grant accounting.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and takes exception to several of the items listed. For example, some of the transactions listed that were missing check requests (both Head Start/Early Head Start and Indirect Cost Pool) were for monthly expenditures like utility bills, insurance, rent and other contractual obligations. Management has not in the past issued a check request each month for these transactions as they are part of the ongoing operation of the programs listed.
Transactions listed with only one signature occurred as an oversight as the banking authority only requires one signature while our policy may indicate two signatures. Management feels the purchase of the truck was procured in agreement with approvals from the funding agency and board as required. Proper documentation was provided and is currently available for further review. Management continues to follow the proper guidelines regarding procurement and purchases related to the policies and procedures of the agency as well as micro purchase guidelines set forth by the Federal awarding agency. The Board of Directors also approved a revision to the policies and procedures requiring two “live” signatures on all checks issued by the agency. There is also an ongoing review of the current policies and procedures and recommendations for changes and updates are forthcoming. Management reserves the right for further review of these findings with the audit firm for additional documentation and resolution.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Federal Award Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment # 2021-006
THE AUTHORITY SHOULD ESTABLISH FORMAL POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR OBTAINING,
RECORDING, AND REPORTING NON-FEDERAL MATCH
HEAD START AND EARLY HEAD START PROGRAMS
Federal Assistance Listing # 93.600
(Questioned Costs - Undetermined)
Condition:
During our audit, we noted that the Authority does not have formal policies and procedures developed that address the requirements to obtain, record and report non-federal match as required by the Department of Health and Human Services - Head Start Programs. It is a statutory requirement for grantees to provide such match as specified under the Head Start Act Section 640(b). Administrative requirements are codified in 45 CFR § 75.306 which states in the Act that a grantee agency must provide 20 percent of the total costs of the Head Start program during a budget period unless a waiver has been granted. During the audit of the year ended June 30, 2021, the Authority had grants awards requiring non-federal match (in-kind) as set forth in the notice of awards (NOA); however, the general ledger did not disclose any in-kind recorded or reported that met the requirements of the federal regulations. We did not observe any evidence of non-federal match being obtained, valued and recorded in accordance with generally accepted principles and federal regulations nor were we presented evidence that a responsible official with HHS approved of a wavier (other than a waiver for the CARES Act
funding documented in the NOA.
Context:
We reviewed grants awarded during the audit period to determine the level of funding granted and the required nonfederal match to be provided by the grantee (the Authority).
Criteria:
In accordance with section 640(b) of the Act, federal financial assistance to a grantee will not exceed 80 percent of the approved total program costs. A grantee must contribute 20 percent as non-federal match each budget period. The responsible HHS official may approve a waiver of all or a portion of the non-federal match requirement on the basis of the grantee’s written application submitted for the budget period and any supporting evidence the responsible HHS official requires. In deciding whether to grant a waiver, the responsible HHS official will consider the circumstances specified at section 640(b) of the Act and whether the grantee has made a reasonable effort to comply with the non-federal match requirement. In addition to internal policy of the Authority, generally accepted accounting principles, Government Auditing Standards and the Uniform Guidance.
Effect:
The transaction could result in the Authority refunding funds to HHS for the failure to obtain and report the required nonfederal match.
Cause:
The failure of the Authority to have formal policies and procedures governing the requirements of obtaining, valuing and recording non-federal match as required by federal regulations. Management and the board of directors must have proper oversight and governance over the tracking, valuing and reporting of non-federal match.
Recommendation:
We recommend that the board of directors and management immediately identify all grants and contracts requiring nonfederal match. The types of non-federal match should be gathered from the various sources, valued using accepted methodologies and techniques, recorded for the appropriate period and reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles and federal regulations.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding. The agency has always utilized the Georgia Pre-K reimbursement it receives during the fiscal year as the matching component for Head Start. The total reimbursement for the reporting period was $814,374. While this amount was not recorded in the general ledger as matching, all matching expenditures were recorded in all the SF425 that were submitted to the funding agency. The agency has all the proper documentation for further review related to Non-Federal Share Matching. The agency has all documentation related to this reimbursement as well as prior audit periods where this amount has been utilized and accepted as the matching component.
The agency will move forward with the development of providing proper oversight and governance of tracking and reporting non-federal match.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.
CLAYTON COUNTY COMMUNITY SERVICES AUTHORITY, INC.
SCHEDULE OF FINDINGS AND QUESTIONED COSTS
Financial Statement Findings and Questioned Costs
June 30, 2021
Comment #2021-001
INTERNAL CONTROLS OVER FINANCIAL STATEMENT PREPARATION, PROPER APPROVAL OF
DISBURSEMENTS, GRANT CLOSE-OUT PROCEDURES AND REQUIRED REGULATORY REPORTING
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES SHOULD IMPROVED
GENERAL
(Repeat Finding)
As part of our auditing procedures, we assisted in the preparation of the financial statements, related disclosures, and the schedule of expenditures of federal awards of the Authority. The preparation of these financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirements, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards, is the responsibility of the grantee. The authoritative and regulatory standards state in summary, that management should authorize, process, reconcile and close-out each grant and contract in a timely manner to ensure proper accounting and reporting of such activity in accordance with the specific professional standards and regulatory requirements. The closeout process is designed to help to reduce the risk of errors, fraud, material misstatement of financial and compliance reporting and recognition of expenditures (or revenue) in the proper period. We noted that the current system of internal controls over financial statements and compliance is not designed to ensure that the objectives are achieved. Further, the capacity of the current staff does not allow for adequate analysis of grants and contracts, other internal shared costs and support services provided, grantor receivables, deferred revenue, allocation of indirect costs and the reconciliation
of bank accounts accurately and in a timely manner. Various regulatory reports were not filed accurately and in a timely manner (i.e., SF-425's for the Head Start Programs and DHS’s State budget reports for the LIHEAP programs). Specifically, revenue was recorded in excess of expenditures for the LIHEAP programs. Therefore, the risk exists that grant receivables and/or cash from the various programs are not recorded properly during the reporting period (interim and annually), which is consistent with our audit findings for the year ended June 30, 2020. The systemic cause appears to be a lack of personnel with the skills, knowledge, and experience with grant accounting and a weakness in the overall system of accounting controls, monitoring and policies and procedures not followed consistently.
Context:
Review of internal control structure of the organization in accordance with Government Auditing Standards.
Criteria:
Controls should be in place to ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP. The auditee shall prepare financial statements that reflect its financial position, results of operations or changes in net assets, and, where appropriate, cash flows for the fiscal year audited. The auditee shall also prepare a schedule of expenditures of Federal awards for the period covered by the auditee's financial statements. [2 CFR §200.510(a) and (b)] Accurate, current, and complete disclosure of the financial results of each Federal award or program in accordance with the reporting requirements set forth in §§200.327 Financial reporting and 200.328 Monitoring and reporting program performance. [2 CFR §200.302(b)(2)]
Effect:
Management may not be able to obtain complete and accurate financial statements on an interim or fiscal year basis to be used for internal or external reporting purposes.
Cause:
Limited personnel with knowledge and/or the ability to assist and provide needed information to aid in financial
statement preparation. The implementation of a new accounting system without an adequate close-out of the old system.
Recommendation:
The degree to which the preparation of the financial statements and related disclosures are prepared by the independent auditor is a control deficiency is determined by the knowledge, skills and experience of those in the organization who are charged with the responsibility of its financial reporting. The Authority has a chief financial officer (CFO) and should hire additional staff (grant accountant and a general ledger accountant) to assist the new fiscal officer. The workload on the CFO is overwhelming. New staff hired should have the adequate skills, knowledge and experience to oversee and/or perform the necessary accounting functions each month. We believe that the CFO with the grant accountant and general ledger accountant should have the overall responsibility of properly reconciling and closing out the accounting system and grant activity each month in an efficient and timely manner so as to eliminate the risk of significant errors occurring. Budget-to-actual schedules should be an integral part of the grant accountant’s basic responsibilities. We further recommend that training be provided to all staff engaged in the financial reporting, allocation and reconciliation functions to ensure that a complete and accurate financial statements close-out process is achieved each month and annually. New policies and procedures should be established that conforms to the Uniform Guidance requirements.
Views of Responsible Officials and Planned Corrective Actions:
The management of Clayton County Community Services Authority, Inc. has reviewed the above referenced finding and fully agrees with the need for improved internal controls over financial statement preparation. Management believes that the proper approval of disbursements was adhered to during the reporting period with minimal deviation and continues to ensure proper policies are followed. Federal reports (SF425’s, LIHEAP) were filed during this period and may not have been properly reviewed during the course of this audit. For example, the LIHEAP reports were reconciled with the assistance of the State Program Specialist to ensure proper return of funds as requested by the funding agency. Management reserves the right to discuss this further as needed for the purpose of this finding. Adequate fiscal personnel staff has continued to be a challenge for the agency as management has done an exhaustive search for additional fiscal personnel and made job offers to qualified individuals only to have them decline the offer at the last moment. We have just offered the position of General Ledger Accountant to an individual and they are expected to start in two weeks. This will assist the CFO in the area of financial controls and reporting. It should also be noted that all bank reconciliations are current and being completed in a timely manner as dictated by our policies and procedures. Management continues to ensure all federal, state, and local and local regulatory reports and completed and submitted
in a timely manner. As stated previously, the CFO worked directly with the State LIHEAP Program Staff to ensure
proper reporting and reconciliation before returning unused funds.