Audit 339220

FY End
2024-03-31
Total Expended
$4.39M
Findings
6
Programs
2
Year: 2024 Accepted: 2025-01-22

Organization Exclusion Status:

Checking exclusion status...

Findings

ID Ref Severity Repeat Requirement
519891 2024-001 Material Weakness Yes N
519892 2024-002 Material Weakness Yes E
519893 2024-003 Material Weakness Yes AB
1096333 2024-001 Material Weakness Yes N
1096334 2024-002 Material Weakness Yes E
1096335 2024-003 Material Weakness Yes AB

Programs

ALN Program Spent Major Findings
14.157 Supportive Housing for the Elderly $4.10M Yes 3
14.856 Lower Income Housing Assistance Program_section 8 Moderate Rehabilitation $287,500 - 0

Contacts

Name Title Type
XAK8JU8NGXY6 Fred Gibbs Auditee
9137091811 Brian Welch Auditor
No contacts on file

Notes to SEFA

Title: BASIS OF PRESENTATION Accounting Policies: Expenditures reported on the Schedule are reported on the GAAP basis of accounting. Such expenditures are recognized following the cost principles contained in the Uniform Guidance, wherein certain types of expenditures are not allowable or are limited as to reimbursement. Negative amounts shown on the Schedule represent adjustments or credits made in the normal course of business to amounts reported as expenditures in prior years. De Minimis Rate Used: N Rate Explanation: The Organization did not elect to use the 10% De Minimis Indirect Cost Rate. The accompanying schedule of expenditures of federal awards (the Schedule) includes the federal award activity of Citadel Gardens, Inc. (the Organization) under programs of the federal government for the year ended March 31, 2024. The information in this Schedule is presented in accordance with the requirements of Title 2 U.S. Code of Federal Regulations Part 200, Uniform Administrative Requirement, Cost Principles, and Audit Requirements for Federal Awards ( Uniform Guidance). Because the Schedule presents only a selected portion of operations of the Organization, it is not intended to and does not present the financial position, changes in net assets, or cash flows of the Organization.
Title: BALANCE OF OUTSTANDING LOAN Accounting Policies: Expenditures reported on the Schedule are reported on the GAAP basis of accounting. Such expenditures are recognized following the cost principles contained in the Uniform Guidance, wherein certain types of expenditures are not allowable or are limited as to reimbursement. Negative amounts shown on the Schedule represent adjustments or credits made in the normal course of business to amounts reported as expenditures in prior years. De Minimis Rate Used: N Rate Explanation: The Organization did not elect to use the 10% De Minimis Indirect Cost Rate. The balance of the Supportive Housing for the Elderly, Section 202 loan as of March 31, 2024 was $4,098,070.

Finding Details

S3800-010: Finding Reference Number 2024-001 (Material Weakness) S3800-011: Program Information Federal Program: Supportive Housing for the Elderly - Section 202 Federal Agency: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Assistance Listing #: 14.157 Pass-through Entity: None Federal Award Identification Number and Year: N/A Type of Compliance Finding: N – Special Tests and Provisions S3800-015: Type of Finding Financial Statement and Federal Awards S3800-016: Finding Resolution Status Unresolved S3800-017: Information on Universe Population Size N/A S3800-018: Sample Size Information N/A S3800-019: Identification of Repeat Finding and Finding Reference Number 2023-001 S3800-020: Criteria The regulatory agreement requires that the Organization’s books and records are maintained in accordance with HUD guidelines and generally accepted accounting principles. S3800-030: Statement of Condition Several misstatements were identified by the auditor in the unaudited financial statements and accounts of the Organization. S3800-032: Cause The Organization lacks adequate internal controls to ensure that books and records are kept accurately and completely. S3800-033: Effect or Potential Effect The Organization was not in compliance with the regulatory agreement requirement to maintain accurate and complete books and accounts. S3800-035: Auditor Non-Compliance Code S – Internal Control Deficiencies S3800-040: Questioned Costs None S3800-045: Reporting Views of Responsible Officials Management agrees with auditor’s finding. S3800-050: Context On the general ledger, accounts receivable, prepaid rents, rent revenue and tenant security deposits did not tie to supporting documentation. The expenses were also not capitalized as per the capitalization policy. The unadjusted net assets did not roll forward correctly from the prior year. S3800-080: Recommendation The Auditor recommends the Organization follows their policies and procedures to ensure that accounting records are kept accurate and complete, and a responsible official should review and sign off on the monthly financial statements. S3800-090: Auditor’s Summary of the Auditee’s Comments on the Findings and Recommendations Concur S3800-130: Response Indicator Agree S3800-140: Completion Date or Proposed Completion Date December 31, 2024 S3800-150: Response See Corrective Action Plan
S3800-010: Finding Reference Number 2024-002 (Material Weakness) S3800-011: Program Information Federal Program: Supportive Housing for the Elderly - Section 202 Federal Agency: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Assistance Listing #: 14.157 Pass-through Entity: None Federal Award Identification Number and Year: N/A Type of Compliance Finding: E – Eligibility S3800-015: Type of Finding Federal Awards S3800-016: Finding Resolution Status Unresolved S3800-017: Information on Universe Population Size 61 S3800-018: Sample Size Information 8 S3800-019: Identification of Repeat Finding and Finding Reference Number 2023-002 S3800-020: Criteria HUD-subsidized, multifamily housing properties must follow specific guidelines for determining eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out; to determine whether they are in compliance with provisions in the HUD Handbook (4350.3). S3800-030: Statement of Condition During our audit of the Organization’s fiscal year ended March 31, 2024 federal award program, we noted the below concerns regarding adherence to compliance requirements • The Organization did not have the necessary supporting documentation to evaluate security deposits and criminal and background information for three tenants in their files • The Organization did not have the necessary supporting documentation to evaluate move-outs for two tenants in their files S3800-032: Cause The Organization did not follow HUD required procedures for eligibility and security deposits. S3800-033: Effect or Potential Effect The Organization was not in compliance with the requirements of HUD related to determining initial eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out. S3800-035: Auditor Non-Compliance Code M – Security deposits S3800-040: Questioned Costs Unknown S3800-045: Reporting Views of Responsible Officials Management agrees with the auditor’s finding. S3800-050: Context The Organization is required to be in compliance with provisions relating to tenant eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out. S3800-080: Recommendation The Organization should follow procedures to ensure tenant eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out and the Organization should review the accuracy / completeness of the documentation being processed in the tenant files on a periodic basis. S3800-090: Auditor’s Summary of the Auditee’s Comments on the Findings and Recommendations Concur S3800-130: Response Indicator Agree S3800-140: Completion Date or Proposed Completion Date December 31, 2024 S3800-150: Response See Corrective Action Plan
S3800-010: Finding Reference Number 2024-003 (Material Weakness) S3800-011: Program Information Federal Program: Supportive Housing for the Elderly - Section 202 Federal Agency: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Assistance Listing #: 14.157 Pass-through Entity: None Federal Award Identification Number and Year: N/A Type of Compliance Finding: A/B – Activities Allowed or Unallowed and Allowable Costs/Cost Principles S3800-015: Type of Finding Federal Awards S3800-016: Finding Resolution Status Unresolved S3800-017: Information on Universe Population Size >250 S3800-018: Sample Size Information 25 S3800-019: Identification of Repeat Finding and Finding Reference Number 2023-003 S3800-020: Criteria Per 24 CFR Part 891, PRAC project funds may be used only for expenses that are reasonable and necessary to the operation of the project as provided for in the Regulatory Agreement between HUD and the project owner. S3800-030: Statement of Condition During our audit of the Organization’s fiscal year ended March 31, 2024 federal award program, we noted that the Organization did not: • Maintain proper documentation to support expenditures for three of the twenty-five samples • Adhere to the HUD approved budget o Manager or Superintendent salaries were greater than approved amount o Payroll expenses were greater than approved amount o Garbage and trash removal expenses were greater than approved amount S3800-032: Cause The Organization did not follow HUD required procedures and the approved budget for activities allowed or unallowed and allowable costs and cost principles and Management is not following processes in place that require supporting documentation to be included with all expenditures. S3800-033: Effect or Potential Effect The Organization was not in compliance with the requirements of HUD related to activities allowed or unallowed and allowable costs and cost principles and expenditures may not be allowed. S3800-035: Auditor Non-Compliance Code S – Internal control deficiencies S3800-040: Questioned Costs $40,295 S3800-045: Reporting Views of Responsible Officials Management agrees with auditor’s finding. S3800-050: Context The Organization is required to be in compliance with provisions relating to activities allowed or unallowed and allowable costs and cost principles. S3800-080: Recommendation The Organization should follow procedures to ensure expenditures are not greater than the HUD approved budget and expenditures include supporting documentation before they are posted to the general ledger. The Organization should also review the accuracy / completeness of all documentation prior to making payment. S3800-090: Auditor’s Summary of the Auditee’s Comments on the Findings and Recommendations Concur S3800-130: Response Indicator Agree S3800-140: Completion Date or Proposed Completion Date December 31, 2024 S3800-150: Response See Corrective Action Plan
S3800-010: Finding Reference Number 2024-001 (Material Weakness) S3800-011: Program Information Federal Program: Supportive Housing for the Elderly - Section 202 Federal Agency: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Assistance Listing #: 14.157 Pass-through Entity: None Federal Award Identification Number and Year: N/A Type of Compliance Finding: N – Special Tests and Provisions S3800-015: Type of Finding Financial Statement and Federal Awards S3800-016: Finding Resolution Status Unresolved S3800-017: Information on Universe Population Size N/A S3800-018: Sample Size Information N/A S3800-019: Identification of Repeat Finding and Finding Reference Number 2023-001 S3800-020: Criteria The regulatory agreement requires that the Organization’s books and records are maintained in accordance with HUD guidelines and generally accepted accounting principles. S3800-030: Statement of Condition Several misstatements were identified by the auditor in the unaudited financial statements and accounts of the Organization. S3800-032: Cause The Organization lacks adequate internal controls to ensure that books and records are kept accurately and completely. S3800-033: Effect or Potential Effect The Organization was not in compliance with the regulatory agreement requirement to maintain accurate and complete books and accounts. S3800-035: Auditor Non-Compliance Code S – Internal Control Deficiencies S3800-040: Questioned Costs None S3800-045: Reporting Views of Responsible Officials Management agrees with auditor’s finding. S3800-050: Context On the general ledger, accounts receivable, prepaid rents, rent revenue and tenant security deposits did not tie to supporting documentation. The expenses were also not capitalized as per the capitalization policy. The unadjusted net assets did not roll forward correctly from the prior year. S3800-080: Recommendation The Auditor recommends the Organization follows their policies and procedures to ensure that accounting records are kept accurate and complete, and a responsible official should review and sign off on the monthly financial statements. S3800-090: Auditor’s Summary of the Auditee’s Comments on the Findings and Recommendations Concur S3800-130: Response Indicator Agree S3800-140: Completion Date or Proposed Completion Date December 31, 2024 S3800-150: Response See Corrective Action Plan
S3800-010: Finding Reference Number 2024-002 (Material Weakness) S3800-011: Program Information Federal Program: Supportive Housing for the Elderly - Section 202 Federal Agency: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Assistance Listing #: 14.157 Pass-through Entity: None Federal Award Identification Number and Year: N/A Type of Compliance Finding: E – Eligibility S3800-015: Type of Finding Federal Awards S3800-016: Finding Resolution Status Unresolved S3800-017: Information on Universe Population Size 61 S3800-018: Sample Size Information 8 S3800-019: Identification of Repeat Finding and Finding Reference Number 2023-002 S3800-020: Criteria HUD-subsidized, multifamily housing properties must follow specific guidelines for determining eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out; to determine whether they are in compliance with provisions in the HUD Handbook (4350.3). S3800-030: Statement of Condition During our audit of the Organization’s fiscal year ended March 31, 2024 federal award program, we noted the below concerns regarding adherence to compliance requirements • The Organization did not have the necessary supporting documentation to evaluate security deposits and criminal and background information for three tenants in their files • The Organization did not have the necessary supporting documentation to evaluate move-outs for two tenants in their files S3800-032: Cause The Organization did not follow HUD required procedures for eligibility and security deposits. S3800-033: Effect or Potential Effect The Organization was not in compliance with the requirements of HUD related to determining initial eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out. S3800-035: Auditor Non-Compliance Code M – Security deposits S3800-040: Questioned Costs Unknown S3800-045: Reporting Views of Responsible Officials Management agrees with the auditor’s finding. S3800-050: Context The Organization is required to be in compliance with provisions relating to tenant eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out. S3800-080: Recommendation The Organization should follow procedures to ensure tenant eligibility and establishing and maintaining security deposits for tenants moving out and the Organization should review the accuracy / completeness of the documentation being processed in the tenant files on a periodic basis. S3800-090: Auditor’s Summary of the Auditee’s Comments on the Findings and Recommendations Concur S3800-130: Response Indicator Agree S3800-140: Completion Date or Proposed Completion Date December 31, 2024 S3800-150: Response See Corrective Action Plan
S3800-010: Finding Reference Number 2024-003 (Material Weakness) S3800-011: Program Information Federal Program: Supportive Housing for the Elderly - Section 202 Federal Agency: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Assistance Listing #: 14.157 Pass-through Entity: None Federal Award Identification Number and Year: N/A Type of Compliance Finding: A/B – Activities Allowed or Unallowed and Allowable Costs/Cost Principles S3800-015: Type of Finding Federal Awards S3800-016: Finding Resolution Status Unresolved S3800-017: Information on Universe Population Size >250 S3800-018: Sample Size Information 25 S3800-019: Identification of Repeat Finding and Finding Reference Number 2023-003 S3800-020: Criteria Per 24 CFR Part 891, PRAC project funds may be used only for expenses that are reasonable and necessary to the operation of the project as provided for in the Regulatory Agreement between HUD and the project owner. S3800-030: Statement of Condition During our audit of the Organization’s fiscal year ended March 31, 2024 federal award program, we noted that the Organization did not: • Maintain proper documentation to support expenditures for three of the twenty-five samples • Adhere to the HUD approved budget o Manager or Superintendent salaries were greater than approved amount o Payroll expenses were greater than approved amount o Garbage and trash removal expenses were greater than approved amount S3800-032: Cause The Organization did not follow HUD required procedures and the approved budget for activities allowed or unallowed and allowable costs and cost principles and Management is not following processes in place that require supporting documentation to be included with all expenditures. S3800-033: Effect or Potential Effect The Organization was not in compliance with the requirements of HUD related to activities allowed or unallowed and allowable costs and cost principles and expenditures may not be allowed. S3800-035: Auditor Non-Compliance Code S – Internal control deficiencies S3800-040: Questioned Costs $40,295 S3800-045: Reporting Views of Responsible Officials Management agrees with auditor’s finding. S3800-050: Context The Organization is required to be in compliance with provisions relating to activities allowed or unallowed and allowable costs and cost principles. S3800-080: Recommendation The Organization should follow procedures to ensure expenditures are not greater than the HUD approved budget and expenditures include supporting documentation before they are posted to the general ledger. The Organization should also review the accuracy / completeness of all documentation prior to making payment. S3800-090: Auditor’s Summary of the Auditee’s Comments on the Findings and Recommendations Concur S3800-130: Response Indicator Agree S3800-140: Completion Date or Proposed Completion Date December 31, 2024 S3800-150: Response See Corrective Action Plan